I’m sorry, Golfer, but if you are trying to suggest that CH management somehow deserve the benefit of the doubt when it comes to Husband/Dobbie, then that’s going to be a hard case to make.
I see no reason to set aside the Karim case. One doesn’t need to “conflate” that case with the others to register clear evidence that the school authorities of the time placed a low premium on child welfare, up the point of wilful blindness, and apparently still can’t bring themselves to confront reality.
The hypocrisy is rank. On multiple occasions Poulton immediately kicked out pupils found in bed together. Yet he decided to keep Karim on to continue his crimes because he was a “success story”. The absurd, unbelievable excuse: he “had no knowledge” massages of “virtually naked” girls were sexual. Somehow all that inflexible rectitude turned into wheedling circumlocutions like “over familiarity” and “undue physicality” [1].
To see Poulton talk of finding a “soft way” of handling paedophilic indecent assault is nauseating, and I am astonished it has not provoked more outrage. The headmaster you think deserves a sympathetic hearing indisputably did this: He sent a sex criminal on his way with a month’s pay and references recommending him “extremely strongly” as a “great all-rounder”, to do who-knows-what elsewhere [2]. (This from the man who once espoused in chapel Plato’s Republic as a model for school order.)
Cairncross, the school’s “designated child protection officer” went all Iran-Contra: “I can’t recall if I reported it to the child protection services or not” -- so clearly she took that role seriously. If victim testimony is to be believed, Sillett threatened negative publicity and lied about forcing Karim to resign, instead leaving a victim to see her abuser around the school. [3]
So sure, let’s “confine ourselves to the facts that we actually know”. We know that these people have a proven record of failing to confront child abuse, of failing in their responsibilities in the most basic way. And even now they seek to justify themselves with excuses that would be comical if the human cost weren’t so apparent.
Now we find that the rumours were true, that Husband was somehow able to take female pupils away for trips over a multi-year period, with the terrible consequences revealed by his victim; and Dobbie was handing out alcohol to children at sexually-oriented dinners at his house. But you want us to believe that school management, these sedulous protectors of children, would have done something if only they’d known? I’m sorry, but that would take a degree of interpretative charity that was markedly absent from Poulton, in particular with regard to these victims.
Don’t you think, having been in the history department at the time, that it might just have been worth telling pupils what happened to their history teacher, possibly even checking if he had done anything else? Amid all the mystery staff disappearances and rumours there wasn’t a single acknowledgement of inappropriate behaviour by the staff, or any attempt to educate children about the dangers. The responsibilities to children were absolutely clear in this regard, even in the early 90s. They should have been clear to anyone with morals, notwithstanding this finegrain evolution of “safeguarding” you think so important.
But then, as far I’m concerned, the CH you were part of was uncaring in a basic way. The wellbeing of students was taken to be by definition enhanced by their presence at the place, regardless of what happened to them. This is what the “unique ethos” translated to in practice. Thus the unheated dormitories, appalling food, pointless hierarchical privileges, and so on. The “Senior Management Team” was more likely to intervene over the quality of lunch marching than rampant bullying. We were all just so very lucky to be there: how could anyone complain?
There is no “casual condemnation” from me. There is disgust based on publicly available information and my own memories of Poulton’s gross sanctimony.
I thought I’d had a miserable enough time there. I didn’t realise I was one of the lucky ones.
[1]
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-sussex-43742967
[2]
https://www.expressandstar.com/news/uk- ... ess-story/
[3]
https://www.independent.ie/world-news/e ... 95540.html